JEE Main · 2019 · Shift-ImediumPERI-091

The size of the isoelectronic species Cl-, Ar and Ca2+ is affected by:

Classification of Elements & Periodicity · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The size of the isoelectronic species Cl^-, Ar and Ca2+^{2+} is affected by:

Options
  1. a

    nuclear charge

  2. b

    azimuthal quantum number of valence shell

  3. c

    electron-electron interaction in the outer orbitals

  4. d

    principal quantum number of valence shell

Correct Answera

nuclear charge

Detailed Solution

🧠 In an isoelectronic set, the electron count, the electron arrangement, and the principal/azimuthal quantum numbers are all identical — only the proton count differs \ceCl\ce{Cl^-}, Ar, \ceCa2+\ce{Ca^{2+}} all have 18 electrons in [\ceNe]3s23p6[\ce{Ne}]\,3s^2\,3p^6 configuration. So:

  • The number of electrons is the same.
  • The orbital arrangement (which orbitals are filled) is the same.
  • The principal quantum number of the valence shell is n=3n = 3 for all three.
  • The azimuthal quantum numbers (\ell) of the highest-occupied subshell are also identical.

The only thing that differs across the three is the number of protons — i.e., nuclear charge ZZ.

🗺️ Eliminate options (b) Azimuthal quantum number — same for all three. Cannot affect size differences. ✗ (c) Electron-electron interactions in outer orbitals — same number of electrons in identical orbitals. The repulsion is identical too. ✗ (d) Principal quantum number — all three valence shells are n=3n = 3. Same value. ✗ (a) Nuclear charge — Cl has Z=17Z=17, Ar has Z=18Z=18, Ca has Z=20Z=20. Different. This is the only varying factor, so this is what changes the size.

⚠️ The trap Option (c) sounds plausible because "more electrons → more repulsion → bigger". But in an isoelectronic set the electron count is by definition fixed. The repulsion doesn't change. Only the proton-count difference matters. When students don't see "isoelectronic" written boldly, they reach for electron-related answers reflexively. Always check the electron count first.

Answer: (a)\boxed{\text{Answer: (a)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Classification of Elements & Periodicity) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The size of the isoelectronic species Cl-, Ar and Ca2+ is affected by: (JEE Main 2019) | Canvas Classes