The size of the isoelectronic species Cl-, Ar and Ca2+ is affected by:
Classification of Elements & Periodicity · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question
The size of the isoelectronic species Cl, Ar and Ca is affected by:
- a✓
nuclear charge
- b
azimuthal quantum number of valence shell
- c
electron-electron interaction in the outer orbitals
- d
principal quantum number of valence shell
nuclear charge
🧠 In an isoelectronic set, the electron count, the electron arrangement, and the principal/azimuthal quantum numbers are all identical — only the proton count differs , Ar, all have 18 electrons in configuration. So:
- The number of electrons is the same.
- The orbital arrangement (which orbitals are filled) is the same.
- The principal quantum number of the valence shell is for all three.
- The azimuthal quantum numbers () of the highest-occupied subshell are also identical.
The only thing that differs across the three is the number of protons — i.e., nuclear charge .
🗺️ Eliminate options (b) Azimuthal quantum number — same for all three. Cannot affect size differences. ✗ (c) Electron-electron interactions in outer orbitals — same number of electrons in identical orbitals. The repulsion is identical too. ✗ (d) Principal quantum number — all three valence shells are . Same value. ✗ (a) Nuclear charge — Cl has , Ar has , Ca has . Different. This is the only varying factor, so this is what changes the size.
⚠️ The trap Option (c) sounds plausible because "more electrons → more repulsion → bigger". But in an isoelectronic set the electron count is by definition fixed. The repulsion doesn't change. Only the proton-count difference matters. When students don't see "isoelectronic" written boldly, they reach for electron-related answers reflexively. Always check the electron count first.
Practice this question with progress tracking
Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Classification of Elements & Periodicity) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.
More JEE Main Classification of Elements & Periodicity PYQs
The correct orders among the following are: Atomic radius: B < Al < Ga < In < Tl Electronegativity: Al < Ga < In < Tl < B Density: Tl < In < Ga < Al < B 1st Ionisation Energy: In < Al < Ga < Tl < B…
Given below are two statements: Statement I: The metallic radius of Al is less than that of Ga. Statement II: The ionic radius of Al3+ is less than that of Ga3+. Choose the most appropriate answer:
Given below are two statements: Statement I: The radii of isoelectronic species increases in the order: Mg2+ < Na+ < F- < O2- Statement II: The magnitude of electron gain enthalpy of halogen…
First ionisation enthalpy values of first four group 15 elements are given below. Choose the correct value for the element that is a main component of apatite family:
The incorrect decreasing order of atomic radii is: