JEE Main · 2024mediumCORD-100

Select the option with correct property:

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Select the option with correct property:

Options
  1. a

    [Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}] and [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-} both diamagnetic

  2. b

    [Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}] and [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-} both paramagnetic

  3. c

    [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-} diamagnetic, [Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}] paramagnetic

  4. d

    [Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}] diamagnetic, [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-} paramagnetic

Correct Answerd

[Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}] diamagnetic, [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-} paramagnetic

Detailed Solution

🧠 Two Tetrahedral Ni Complexes, Opposite Magnetic States

Both [Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}] and [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-} are tetrahedral, but their oxidation states differ:

  • [Ni(CO)4][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}]: Ni(0), d10\mathrm{d^{10}} → all electrons paired → diamagnetic (μ=0\mu = 0).
  • [NiCl4]2[\mathrm{NiCl_4}]^{2-}: Ni(II), d8\mathrm{d^8}, tetrahedral. Tetrahedral d8\mathrm{d^8}: e4t24\mathrm{e^4 t_2^4} → 2 unpaired → paramagnetic (μ=2.83\mu = 2.83 BM).

Match: Ni(CO)₄ diamagnetic, NiCl₄²⁻ paramagnetic → option (4).

🗺️ Why CO Drives Ni to Zero

CO is a neutral ligand and a strong π-acceptor. To stabilise the Ni–C π-back-bond, Ni donates its 4s and 3d electrons into CO π* orbitals. The formal oxidation state stays 0 (CO is neutral, complex is neutral) — and Ni ends up d10\mathrm{d^{10}}, fully paired.

The "Carbonyl = M(0) = dmaxn\mathrm{d^n_{max}}" Pattern

Binary carbonyls — [Ni(CO)4],[Fe(CO)5],[Cr(CO)6][\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}], [\mathrm{Fe(CO)_5}], [\mathrm{Cr(CO)_6}] — always have the metal in 0 oxidation state, with maximum d-electron count for that metal. They obey the 18-electron rule and are nearly always diamagnetic.

⚠️ Don't Lump Ni(CO)₄ and NiCl₄²⁻

Same metal, same coordination number (4), same geometry (tetrahedral) — opposite magnetic behaviour. The difference is the oxidation state, not the geometry.

Answer: (4) Ni(CO)₄ diamagnetic, NiCl₄²⁻ paramagnetic\boxed{\text{Answer: (4) Ni(CO)₄ diamagnetic, NiCl₄²⁻ paramagnetic}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.