JEE Main · 2021mediumCORD-067

Which one of the following metal complexes is most stable?

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which one of the following metal complexes is most stable?

Options
  1. a

    [Co(en)(NH3)4]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)(NH_3)_4}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

  2. b

    [Co(en)3]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

  3. c

    [Co(en)2(NH3)2]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_2(NH_3)_2}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

  4. d

    [Co(NH3)6]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(NH_3)_6}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

Correct Answerb

[Co(en)3]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

Detailed Solution

🧠 More Chelate Rings = More Stable

The chelate effect: complexes with chelating (multidentate) ligands are more stable than those with monodentate ligands of similar donor type. Each chelate ring adds extra entropy stability.

Order of NH3\mathrm{NH_3} replacement by ethylenediamine (en):

[Co(NH3)6]<[Co(en)(NH3)4]<[Co(en)2(NH3)2]<[Co(en)3].[\mathrm{Co(NH_3)_6}] < [\mathrm{Co(en)(NH_3)_4}] < [\mathrm{Co(en)_2(NH_3)_2}] < [\mathrm{Co(en)_3}].

(0 rings \to 1 ring \to 2 rings \to 3 rings.)

The most stable is [Co(en)3]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2} — three 5-membered chelate rings.

🗺️ Why Chelation Wins (the Entropy Story)

Replacing 2 NH3\mathrm{NH_3} by 1 en doesn't change the enthalpy much (Co–N bonds either way), but it increases the number of free particles in solution: 1 en displaces 2 NH3\mathrm{NH_3}, so Δn>0ΔS>0\Delta n > 0 \Rightarrow \Delta S > 0. Positive entropy → more negative ΔG\Delta G → bigger formation constant.

The Ring-Counting Shortcut

When all four options have the same donor type (here, all-nitrogen), pick the option with the most chelate rings. Don't bother computing log K values — ring count alone settles the ranking 95% of the time.

⚠️ Bigger Ring ≠ More Stable

5-membered chelate rings are most stable. en gives 5-rings (M–N–C–C–N back to M). A 4-membered or 7-membered ring is less stable than 5. So "more rings" only beats "fewer rings" when ring sizes are comparable.

Answer: (2) [Co(en)3]Cl2\boxed{\text{Answer: (2) } [\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Which one of the following metal complexes is most stable? (JEE Main 2021) | Canvas Classes