JEE Main · 2021mediumCORD-067

Which one of the following metal complexes is most stable?

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which one of the following metal complexes is most stable?

Options
  1. a

    [Co(en)(NH3)4]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)(NH_3)_4}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

  2. b

    [Co(en)3]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

  3. c

    [Co(en)2(NH3)2]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_2(NH_3)_2}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

  4. d

    [Co(NH3)6]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(NH_3)_6}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

Correct Answerb

[Co(en)3]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2}

Detailed Solution

🧠 More Chelate Rings = More Stable

The chelate effect: complexes with chelating (multidentate) ligands are more stable than those with monodentate ligands of similar donor type. Each chelate ring adds extra entropy stability.

Order of NH3\mathrm{NH_3} replacement by ethylenediamine (en):

[Co(NH3)6]<[Co(en)(NH3)4]<[Co(en)2(NH3)2]<[Co(en)3].[\mathrm{Co(NH_3)_6}] < [\mathrm{Co(en)(NH_3)_4}] < [\mathrm{Co(en)_2(NH_3)_2}] < [\mathrm{Co(en)_3}].

(0 rings \to 1 ring \to 2 rings \to 3 rings.)

The most stable is [Co(en)3]Cl2[\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2} — three 5-membered chelate rings.

🗺️ Why Chelation Wins (the Entropy Story)

Replacing 2 NH3\mathrm{NH_3} by 1 en doesn't change the enthalpy much (Co–N bonds either way), but it increases the number of free particles in solution: 1 en displaces 2 NH3\mathrm{NH_3}, so Δn>0ΔS>0\Delta n > 0 \Rightarrow \Delta S > 0. Positive entropy → more negative ΔG\Delta G → bigger formation constant.

The Ring-Counting Shortcut

When all four options have the same donor type (here, all-nitrogen), pick the option with the most chelate rings. Don't bother computing log K values — ring count alone settles the ranking 95% of the time.

⚠️ Bigger Ring ≠ More Stable

5-membered chelate rings are most stable. en gives 5-rings (M–N–C–C–N back to M). A 4-membered or 7-membered ring is less stable than 5. So "more rings" only beats "fewer rings" when ring sizes are comparable.

Answer: (2) [Co(en)3]Cl2\boxed{\text{Answer: (2) } [\mathrm{Co(en)_3}]\mathrm{Cl_2}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.