JEE Main · 2023 · Shift-IhardHALO-064

2-Methyl propyl bromide reacts with C2H5O and gives 'A' whereas on reaction with C2H5OH it gives 'B'. The mechanism…

Haloalkanes & Haloarenes · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

2-Methyl propyl bromide reacts with \ceC2H5O\ce{C2H5O} and gives 'A' whereas on reaction with \ceC2H5OH\ce{C2H5OH} it gives 'B'. The mechanism followed in these reactions and the products 'A' and 'B' respectively are:

Options
  1. a

    SN2S_N2, A = iso-butyl ethyl ether; SN1S_N1, B = tert-butyl ethyl ether

  2. b

    SN1S_N1, A = tert-butyl ethyl ether; SN2S_N2, B = iso-butyl ethyl ether

  3. c

    SN2S_N2, A = tert-butyl ethyl ether; SN2S_N2, B = iso-butyl ethyl ether

  4. d

    SN2S_N2, A = 2-butyl ethyl ether; SN1S_N1, B = tert-butyl ethyl ether

Correct Answerd

SN2S_N2, A = 2-butyl ethyl ether; SN1S_N1, B = tert-butyl ethyl ether

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Identify the substrate

2-Methylpropyl bromide = Isobutyl bromide

Structure: \ce(CH3)2CHCH2Br\ce{(CH3)2CH-CH2Br}

This is a primary halide (Br on primary carbon).

Step 2: Reaction with \ceC2H5O\ce{C2H5O-} (ethoxide ion)

Reagent: Strong nucleophile (ethoxide ion)

Mechanism: SN2S_N2 (primary halide + strong nucleophile)

\ce(CH3)2CHCH2Br+C2H5O>(CH3)2CHCH2OC2H5+Br\ce{(CH3)2CH-CH2Br + C2H5O- -> (CH3)2CH-CH2-O-C2H5 + Br-}

Product A = Isobutyl ethyl ether (2-methylpropyl ethyl ether)

Step 3: Reaction with \ceC2H5OH\ce{C2H5OH} (ethanol)

Reagent: Weak nucleophile (ethanol)

Mechanism: For primary halide with weak nucleophile:

  • SN2S_N2 is still possible but slow
  • Or SN1S_N1 if carbocation can rearrange

Carbocation rearrangement:

If SN1S_N1 occurs:

  1. \ce(CH3)2CHCH2Br>(CH3)2CHCH2++Br\ce{(CH3)2CH-CH2Br -> (CH3)2CH-CH2+ + Br-} (1° carbocation)
  2. Hydride shift: \ce(CH3)2CHCH2+>(CH3)3C+\ce{(CH3)2CH-CH2+ -> (CH3)3C+} (3° carbocation, more stable)
  3. \ce(CH3)3C++C2H5OH>(CH3)3COC2H5\ce{(CH3)3C+ + C2H5OH -> (CH3)3C-O-C2H5}

Product B = tert-Butyl ethyl ether (after rearrangement)

But wait, primary halides typically don't undergo SN1S_N1 easily. Let me reconsider.

Actually, with weak nucleophile (ethanol), the reaction is very slow. If it does proceed via SN1S_N1, rearrangement is likely.

Step 4: Match with options

Looking at option (a):

  • SN2S_N2 with \ceC2H5O\ce{C2H5O-} → isobutyl ethyl ether ✓
  • SN1S_N1 with \ceC2H5OH\ce{C2H5OH} → tert-butyl ethyl ether (rearranged) ✓

Answer: (a)

Key Points:

  • Strong nucleophile (\ceRO\ce{RO-}) → SN2S_N2 → no rearrangement
  • Weak nucleophile (\ceROH\ce{ROH}) → SN1S_N1 (if possible) → rearrangement likely
  • Carbocation rearrangement: 1° → 2° or 3° (more stable)
  • Hydride shift: H moves with its bonding electrons
  • Methyl shift: \ceCH3\ce{CH3} moves with its bonding electrons

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Haloalkanes & Haloarenes) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

2-Methyl propyl bromide reacts with C2H5O and gives 'A' whereas on reaction with C2H5OH it gives… (JEE Main 2023) | Canvas Classes