JEE Main · 2023 · Shift-IImediumHALO-060

Decreasing order towards SN1 reaction for the following compounds is:

Haloalkanes & Haloarenes · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Decreasing order towards SN1S_N1 reaction for the following compounds is: image

Options
  1. a

    (a) > (c) > (d) > (b)

  2. b

    (a) > (b) > (c) > (d)

  3. c

    (b) > (d) > (c) > (a)

  4. d

    (d) > (b) > (c) > (a)

Correct Answerc

(b) > (d) > (c) > (a)

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Understand SN1S_N1 mechanism for aryl halides

Problem: Aryl halides (halogen directly on benzene) generally do not undergo SN1S_N1 because:

  • Aryl carbocations are extremely unstable (sp² hybridized)
  • No resonance stabilization
  • Very high energy

But if the question asks about SN1S_N1 reactivity, we consider relative stability if forced to react.

Step 2: Analyze substituent effects

For SN1S_N1, we need to stabilize the carbocation (if it forms).

Electron-donating groups (EDG): Stabilize carbocation (increase reactivity) Electron-withdrawing groups (EWG): Destabilize carbocation (decrease reactivity)

Step 3: Analyze each compound

(a) p-Nitrochlorobenzene:

  • \ceNO2\ce{NO2} at para: Strong EWG
  • Destabilizes any positive charge
  • Least reactive for SN1S_N1

(b) p-Methoxychlorobenzene:

  • \ceOCH3\ce{-OCH3} at para: Strong EDG (resonance)
  • Stabilizes positive charge through resonance
  • Most reactive for SN1S_N1 ✓✓

(c) m-Dichlorobenzene:

  • Cl at meta: Weak EWG (inductive only, no resonance)
  • Slightly destabilizes
  • Low reactivity

(d) Chlorobenzene:

  • No additional substituent
  • Baseline reactivity
  • Between (b) and (c)

Step 4: Order reactivity

Decreasing order for SN1S_N1:

(b) [p-OCH₃] > (d) [plain] > (c) [m-Cl] > (a) [p-NO₂]

EDG (stabilizes) > neutral > weak EWG > strong EWG (destabilizes)

Answer: (c) (b) > (d) > (c) > (a)

Key Points:

  • SN1S_N1: Carbocation stability is key
  • EDG: Stabilize carbocation → faster SN1S_N1
  • EWG: Destabilize carbocation → slower SN1S_N1
  • Resonance effects: Stronger than inductive effects
  • Para/ortho positions: Allow resonance with substituent
  • Meta position: Only inductive effect (no resonance)

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Haloalkanes & Haloarenes) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Decreasing order towards SN1 reaction for the following compounds is: (JEE Main 2023) | Canvas Classes