JEE Main · 2024 · Shift-IImediumPOC-015

The correct statements among the following, for a "chromatography" purification method is:

Practical Organic Chemistry · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The correct statements among the following, for a "chromatography" purification method is:

Options
  1. a

    Organic compounds run faster than solvent in the thin layer chromatographic plate.

  2. b

    Non-polar compounds are retained at top and polar compounds come down in column chromatography.

  3. c

    RfR_f of a polar compound is smaller than that of a non-polar compound.

  4. d

    RfR_f is an integral value.

Correct Answerc

RfR_f of a polar compound is smaller than that of a non-polar compound.

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Analyse Statement (a)

"Organic compounds run faster than solvent in TLC"

False. By definition, Rf<1R_f < 1 always. The solvent front travels faster than any compound. If a compound moved at the same speed as the solvent, it would have Rf=1R_f = 1 — meaning zero adsorption. In practice, compounds always interact with the adsorbent to some extent, so RfR_f is always less than 1.

Step 2: Analyse Statement (b)

"Non-polar compounds are retained at top; polar compounds come down in column chromatography"

False — this is the exact opposite of reality. On a polar adsorbent (silica gel/alumina):

  • Polar compounds → stronger adsorption → move SLOWLY → retained higher up in the column
  • Non-polar compounds → weak adsorption → move FAST → elute first (exit at the bottom)

Step 3: Analyse Statement (c)

"RfR_f of a polar compound is smaller than that of a non-polar compound"

True. On polar adsorbents (silica gel, alumina):

  • Polar compound → stronger adsorption → shorter distance traveled → lower RfR_f
  • Non-polar compound → weaker adsorption → longer distance traveled → higher RfR_f Rf(polar)<Rf(non-polar)R_f(\text{polar}) < R_f(\text{non-polar})

Step 4: Analyse Statement (d)

"RfR_f is an integral value"

False. RfR_f is always a decimal fraction strictly between 0 and 1 (e.g., 0.4, 0.7, 0.82). It is never a whole number.

Conclusion: Only statement (c) is correct → Option (c)

Key Points to Remember:

  • RfR_f range: 0 to 1 (decimal, never > 1, never an integer)
  • Solvent front always moves faster than any compound in TLC
  • Polar compound → stronger adsorption → lower RfR_f → retained longer in column
  • Non-polar compound → weaker adsorption → higher RfR_f → elutes first

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Practical Organic Chemistry) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The correct statements among the following, for a "chromatography" purification method is: (JEE Main 2024) | Canvas Classes