JEE Main · 2024 · Shift-ImediumRDX-035

Among the following halogens F2, Cl2, Br2 and I2. Which can undergo disproportionation reactions?

Redox Reactions · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Among the following halogens F2\mathrm{F_2}, Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2}, Br2\mathrm{Br_2} and I2\mathrm{I_2}. Which can undergo disproportionation reactions?

Options
  1. a

    F2\mathrm{F_2}, Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2} and Br2\mathrm{Br_2}

  2. b

    F2\mathrm{F_2} and Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2}

  3. c

    Only I2\mathrm{I_2}

  4. d

    Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2}, Br2\mathrm{Br_2} and I2\mathrm{I_2}

Correct Answerd

Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2}, Br2\mathrm{Br_2} and I2\mathrm{I_2}

Detailed Solution

Disproportionation requires the element to simultaneously increase and decrease its oxidation state. For halogens (X₂, OS = 0), they must be able to form both X\mathrm{X^-} (OS = 1-1) and XO\mathrm{XO^-} or higher oxyanions (OS > 0).

Step 1 — F2\mathrm{F_2}: Fluorine is the most electronegative element and has no positive oxidation states. It cannot be oxidised to positive states → cannot disproportionate

Example: F2+H2OHF+HOF\mathrm{F_2 + H_2O \rightarrow HF + HOF} — but this is not disproportionation (F stays at 0 in HOF and goes to -1 in HF, but HOF has O at -1, not F at +1).

Step 2 — Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2}, Br2\mathrm{Br_2}, I2\mathrm{I_2}: These halogens can form positive oxidation states (in oxyanions): Cl2+2OHCl+ClO+H2O\mathrm{Cl_2 + 2OH^- \rightarrow Cl^- + ClO^- + H_2O} Cl: 010 \rightarrow -1 (reduced) and 0+10 \rightarrow +1 (oxidised) → Disproportionation ✓

Similarly Br2\mathrm{Br_2} and I2\mathrm{I_2} can disproportionate in alkaline conditions.

Answer: Option (4) — Cl2\mathrm{Cl_2}, Br2\mathrm{Br_2} and I2\mathrm{I_2}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Redox Reactions) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.