JEE Main · 2020hardCORD-223

Consider that d⁶ metal ion (M²⁺) forms a complex with aqua ligands, and the spin only magnetic moment of the complex is…

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Consider that d⁶ metal ion (M²⁺) forms a complex with aqua ligands, and the spin only magnetic moment of the complex is 4.90 BM. The geometry and the crystal field stabilization energy of the complex is:

Options
  1. a

    octahedral and 2.4Δ0+2P-2.4\Delta_0 + 2P

  2. b

    tetrahedral and 0.6Δt-0.6\Delta_t

  3. c

    octahedral and 1.6Δ0-1.6\Delta_0

  4. d

    tetrahedral and 1.6Δt+1P-1.6\Delta_t + 1P

Correct Answerb

tetrahedral and 0.6Δt-0.6\Delta_t

Detailed Solution

🧠 μ = 4.90 BM Implies 4 Unpaired Electrons

μ=n(n+2)\mu = \sqrt{n(n+2)}. For μ = 4.90: 4.90=n(n+2)n(n+2)=24n=44.90 = \sqrt{n(n+2)} \Rightarrow n(n+2) = 24 \Rightarrow n = 4

🗺️ d⁶ With 4 Unpaired

For d⁶ M(II), 4 unpaired electrons matches:

  • Octahedral HS d⁶ → t2g4eg2t_{2g}^4 e_g^2 → 4 unpaired ✓
  • Tetrahedral d⁶ → e3t23e^3 t_2^3 → 4 unpaired ✓ (Td is always HS for first-row TM)

Both could give 4 unpaired. Need additional reasoning.

🗺️ Aqua Ligand Strength

H₂O is weak/intermediate field. For d⁶ M(II) with H₂O:

  • Octahedral HS d⁶: t2g4eg2t_{2g}^4 e_g^2, CFSE = 0.4Δo-0.4\Delta_o + pairing penalty PP in t2g4t_{2g}^4 pair → 0.4Δo+P-0.4\Delta_o + P (1 extra pair). Or just 0.4Δo-0.4\Delta_o if pairing ignored.
  • Tetrahedral d⁶: e3t23e^3 t_2^3, CFSE = 3(0.6Δt)+3(+0.4Δt)=1.8Δt+1.2Δt=0.6Δt3(-0.6\Delta_t) + 3(+0.4\Delta_t) = -1.8\Delta_t + 1.2\Delta_t = -0.6\Delta_t.

🗺️ Match the Options

Looking at options:

  • Octahedral and 2.4Δo+2P-2.4\Delta_o + 2P: would need 6 paired electrons (LS) — μ=0, not 4.90 BM. ✗
  • Tetrahedral and 0.6Δt-0.6\Delta_t: matches Td d⁶ exactly. ✓
  • Octahedral and 1.6Δo-1.6\Delta_o: would be Td d⁵ (e2t23e^2 t_2^3 = 2(0.6)+3(+0.4)=02(-0.6) + 3(+0.4) = 0) or some other config — doesn't match d⁶ HS oct CFSE.
  • Tetrahedral and 1.6Δt+1P-1.6\Delta_t + 1P: doesn't match standard Td d⁶ formula.

So the answer is (2) Tetrahedral and 0.6Δt-0.6\Delta_t.

Td CFSE Coefficients

Td d-orbital splitting is inverted vs Oct: ee is lower (coeff 0.6Δt-0.6\Delta_t), t2t_2 is upper (coeff +0.4Δt+0.4\Delta_t).

⚠️ Td Always HS

For first-row tetrahedral complexes, Δt(4/9)Δo\Delta_t \approx (4/9)\Delta_o — too small to overcome pairing. So Td is universally HS for first-row TMs.

Answer: (2) tetrahedral and 0.6Δt\boxed{\text{Answer: (2) tetrahedral and } -0.6\Delta_t}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Consider that d⁶ metal ion (M²⁺) forms a complex with aqua ligands, and the spin only magnetic… (JEE Main 2020) | Canvas Classes