JEE Main · 2023mediumCORD-048

Correct order of spin only magnetic moment of the following complex ions is: (At. No. Fe: 26, Co: 27) (1) [FeF6]3-…

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Correct order of spin only magnetic moment of the following complex ions is: (At. No. Fe: 26, Co: 27) (1) [FeF6]3>[CoF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} (2) [Co(C2O4)3]3>[CoF6]3>[FeF6]3[\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} (3) [FeF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3>[CoF6]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} (4) [CoF6]3>[FeF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-}

Options
  1. a

    [FeF6]3>[CoF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-}

  2. b

    [Co(C2O4)3]3>[CoF6]3>[FeF6]3[\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-}

  3. c

    [FeF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3>[CoF6]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-}

  4. d

    [CoF6]3>[FeF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-}

Correct Answera

[FeF6]3>[CoF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-}

Detailed Solution

🧠 Three d⁵/d⁶ Cases

Quick d-count and field-strength check:

  • [FeF6]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-}: Fe3+d5\mathrm{Fe^{3+}\,d^5} + weak F\mathrm{F^-} → high-spin → 5 unpaired → μ ≈ 5.92 BM.
  • [CoF6]3[\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-}: Co3+d6\mathrm{Co^{3+}\,d^6} + weak F\mathrm{F^-} → high-spin → 4 unpaired → μ ≈ 4.90 BM.
  • [Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-}: Co3+d6\mathrm{Co^{3+}\,d^6} + oxalate (strong enough on Co3+\mathrm{Co^{3+}}) → low-spin → 0 unpaired → μ = 0.

Decreasing μ: [FeF6]3>[CoF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} → option (1).

🗺️ Why Oxalate Beats F\mathrm{F^-}

In the spectrochemical series, F\mathrm{F^-} < H2O\mathrm{H_2O} < oxalate < NH3\mathrm{NH_3} < en. With Co3+\mathrm{Co^{3+}} (high charge density), oxalate is just strong enough to push Δo\Delta_o above the pairing energy — flipping d⁶ into low-spin. F\mathrm{F^-}, sitting at the bottom of the series, leaves the same Co³⁺ in high-spin.

The "Same Metal, Different Spin" Map

For Co3+(d6)\mathrm{Co^{3+}}\,(\mathrm{d^6}):

  • High-spin (4 unpaired, μ ≈ 4.9): with F\mathrm{F^-}, sometimes H2O\mathrm{H_2O} in special cases.
  • Low-spin (0 unpaired, μ = 0): with NH3\mathrm{NH_3}, en, oxalate, CN\mathrm{CN^-}.

Halides and bare oxide are the only ligands that consistently keep Co(III) high-spin.

⚠️ Don't Pair Fluoride with Oxalate Reflexively

Both [FeF6]3[\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} and [Co(C2O4)3]3[\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-} have charge 3-3, but they sit at opposite ends of the spin spectrum. Charge similarity doesn't predict magnetic similarity. Always check d-count and ligand identity together.

Answer: (1) [FeF6]3>[CoF6]3>[Co(C2O4)3]3\boxed{\text{Answer: (1) } [\mathrm{FeF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{CoF_6}]^{3-} > [\mathrm{Co(C_2O_4)_3}]^{3-}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.