JEE Main · 2024 · Shift-ImediumPOC-048

The Lassiagne's extract is boiled with dil HNO3 before testing for halogens because,

Practical Organic Chemistry · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The Lassiagne's extract is boiled with dil \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3} before testing for halogens because,

Options
  1. a

    \ceAgCN\ce{AgCN} is soluble in \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}

  2. b

    Silver halides are soluble in \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}

  3. c

    \ceAg2S\ce{Ag2S} is soluble in \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}

  4. d

    \ceNa2S\ce{Na2S} and \ceNaCN\ce{NaCN} are decomposed by \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}

Correct Answerd

\ceNa2S\ce{Na2S} and \ceNaCN\ce{NaCN} are decomposed by \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Understand the Problem

In Lassaigne's test, before testing for halogens with \ceAgNO3\ce{AgNO3}, the sodium extract is boiled with dilute \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}. Why?

The sodium extract may contain:

  • \ceNaCN\ce{NaCN} (from nitrogen)
  • \ceNa2S\ce{Na2S} (from sulphur)
  • \ceNaX\ce{NaX} (from halogens)

Step 2: The Problem with \ceAgNO3\ce{AgNO3} Test Without Pre-treatment

If we add \ceAgNO3\ce{AgNO3} directly to the extract without acidification:

  • \ceNaCN+AgNO3>AgCN(v)\ce{NaCN + AgNO3 -> AgCN(v)} — white precipitate (mimics AgCl)
  • \ceNa2S+2AgNO3>Ag2S(v)\ce{Na2S + 2AgNO3 -> Ag2S(v)} — black precipitate (masks halide test)

Both \ceAgCN\ce{AgCN} and \ceAg2S\ce{Ag2S} would interfere with and confuse the halide test.

Step 3: Why Boil with Dilute \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3}?

Boiling with dilute \ceHNO3\ce{HNO3} decomposes \ceNaCN\ce{NaCN} and \ceNa2S\ce{Na2S}:

  • \ceNaCN+HNO3>HCN(gas,volatile)+NaNO3\ce{NaCN + HNO3 -> HCN (gas, volatile) + NaNO3}\ceCN\ce{CN^-} is destroyed
  • \ceNa2S+2HNO3>H2S(gas,expelled)+2NaNO3\ce{Na2S + 2HNO3 -> H2S (gas, expelled) + 2NaNO3}\ceS2\ce{S^{2-}} is removed

Now only \ceNaX\ce{NaX} (halide) remains, which then reacts with \ceAgNO3\ce{AgNO3} to give an unambiguous precipitate.

Step 4: Evaluate Each Option

(a) AgCN is soluble in HNO₃ — AgCN is actually NOT soluble in dilute HNO₃; this is not the reason.

(b) Silver halides are soluble in HNO₃ — Actually, silver halides are INSOLUBLE in HNO₃. This statement is incorrect and cannot be the reason.

(c) Ag₂S is soluble in HNO₃\ceAg2S\ce{Ag2S} dissolves in dilute HNO₃, but this is not the primary reason.

(d) Na₂S and NaCN are decomposed by HNO₃ ✅ — This is the correct reason. HNO₃ decomposes Na₂S and NaCN, eliminating interfering ions before the halide test.

Answer: (d)

Key Points to Remember:

  • Boiling with dilute HNO₃ before halide test removes interfering CN⁻ and S²⁻
  • Without this step, AgCN and Ag₂S would form and confuse results
  • Silver halides: AgCl (white), AgBr (pale yellow), AgI (yellow) — all insoluble in dilute HNO₃
  • AgCl and AgBr dissolve in \ceNH3(aq)\ce{NH3(aq)}; AgI does not

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Practical Organic Chemistry) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The Lassiagne's extract is boiled with dil HNO3 before testing for halogens because, (JEE Main 2024) | Canvas Classes