JEE Main · 2023 · Shift-ImediumPOC-018

Using column chromatography, mixture of two compounds 'A' and 'B' was separated. 'A' eluted first, this indicates 'B'…

Practical Organic Chemistry · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Using column chromatography, mixture of two compounds 'A' and 'B' was separated. 'A' eluted first, this indicates 'B' has

Options
  1. a

    Low RfR_f, weaker adsorption

  2. b

    High RfR_f, stronger adsorption

  3. c

    High RfR_f, weaker adsorption

  4. d

    Low RfR_f, stronger adsorption

Correct Answerd

Low RfR_f, stronger adsorption

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Understand the Setup

In column chromatography:

  • A polar adsorbent (silica gel or alumina) is the stationary phase
  • A liquid solvent is the mobile phase
  • Compound A eluted first → it spends less time on the column
  • Compound B eluted second → it is retained longer on the column

Step 2: Relate Elution Order to Adsorption Strength

Compound that elutes first (A):

  • Has weaker adsorption on the stationary phase
  • Has higher RfR_f value (moves more with the solvent)

Compound that elutes second (B):

  • Has stronger adsorption on the stationary phase
  • Has lower RfR_f value (moves less with the solvent)

Step 3: Determine Properties of Compound B

Since B elutes after A:

  • B has stronger adsorption on the adsorbent → B is more polar
  • B has lower RfR_f than A

Step 4: Evaluate Options

| Option | RfR_f | Adsorption | Correct? | |---|---|---|---| | (a) | Low | Weaker | ❌ — contradiction (low RfR_f means stronger adsorption) | | (b) | High | Stronger | ❌ — contradiction (high RfR_f means weaker adsorption) | | (c) | High | Weaker | ❌ — B has low RfR_f, not high | | (d) | Low | Stronger | ✅ — consistent with B eluting after A |

Answer: (d) Low RfR_f, stronger adsorption

Key Points to Remember:

  • Elutes first = weaker adsorption = higher RfR_f (less polar compound)
  • Elutes last = stronger adsorption = lower RfR_f (more polar compound)
  • RfR_f and adsorption strength are inversely related on a polar adsorbent
  • This relationship is fundamental to understanding both TLC and column chromatography

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Practical Organic Chemistry) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Using column chromatography, mixture of two compounds 'A' and 'B' was separated. 'A' eluted first,… (JEE Main 2023) | Canvas Classes