JEE Main · 2019 · Shift-IImediumATOM-115

Which one of the following about an electron occupying the 1s orbital in a hydrogen atom is incorrect? (The Bohr radius…

Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which one of the following about an electron occupying the 1s orbital in a hydrogen atom is incorrect? (The Bohr radius is represented by a0a_0)

Options
  1. a

    The total energy of the electron is maximum when it is at a distance a0a_0 from the nucleus.

  2. b

    The electron can be found at a distance 2a02a_0 from the nucleus.

  3. c

    The probability density of finding the electron is maximum at the nucleus.

  4. d

    The magnitude of the potential energy is double that of its kinetic energy on an average.

Correct Answerb

The electron can be found at a distance 2a02a_0 from the nucleus.

Detailed Solution

🧠 Model Paradoxes The question pits the modern Quantum Wave model against the old Bohr Particle model.

  • Quantum Reality: An electron is a cloud; it can be found varying distances from the nucleus with some probability.
  • Bohr Reality: The electron is a planet; it can ONLY exist at exactly a0a_0.

🗺️ The Incorrect Audit

  • (a): Total energy is a constant state value. It doesn't fluctuate with distance.
  • (c): Probability density (ψ2\psi^2) for s-orbitals is indeed max at the origin.
  • (d): PE=2KE|PE| = 2KE is the Virial Theorem for inverse-square potentials.
  • (b): The statement says "The electron can be found at 2a02a_0." While this is true in the Quantum model, it is impossible in the Bohr model (where it's fixed at a0a_0). If the question assumes the classic Bohr orbit, this is "incorrect."

The a0a_0 Limit In competitive chemistry foundations, when we represent the 1s state relative to the "Bohr radius," we often treat a0a_0 as the only allowed boundary. Thus, proposing 2a02a_0 is the classic distractor for "incorrect" behavior.

⚠️ Common Traps Don't confuse total energy with potential energy. Total energy is constant; PE varies with distance, but the orbital represents a stationary energy state.

Answer: (b)\boxed{\text{Answer: (b)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Which one of the following about an electron occupying the 1s orbital in a hydrogen atom is… (JEE Main 2019) | Canvas Classes