JEE Main · 2021 · Shift-IIhardPERI-077

The first ionization energy of magnesium is smaller, as compared to that of elements X and Y, but higher than that of…

Classification of Elements & Periodicity · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The first ionization energy of magnesium is smaller, as compared to that of elements X and Y, but higher than that of Z. The elements X, Y and Z, respectively, are:

Options
  1. a

    chlorine, lithium and sodium

  2. b

    argon, lithium and sodium

  3. c

    argon, chlorine and sodium

  4. d

    neon, sodium and chlorine

Correct Answerc

argon, chlorine and sodium

Detailed Solution

🧠 Mg sits in the middle of Period 3 — to find X, Y (higher IE) and Z (lower IE), look for elements right of Mg in Period 3 vs Group 1 below Mg IE1(\ceMg)=737kJ/molIE_1(\ce{Mg}) = 737\,kJ/mol. Across Period 3, IE rises (with two anomalies). Down Group 1, IE falls. So elements ABOVE Mg in IE are roughly Si, P, S, Cl, Ar (further right in Period 3) — and below Mg in IE are alkali metals like Na, K.

🗺️ Identify Z (lower than Mg) Z must have IE1<737IE_1 < 737. Na has IE1=496IE_1 = 496 — yes, lower than Mg. So Z = Na.

Identify X and Y (higher than Mg) Both must exceed 737. Among the options: Cl has IE1=1251IE_1 = 1251 — higher. Ar has IE1=1521IE_1 = 1521 — higher (and the highest in Period 3). Li has IE1=520IE_1 = 520 — LOWER than Mg, so Li cannot be X or Y. This rules out (a) and (b). Ne is in Period 2, not Period 3, but could still be considered. Ne has IE1=2080IE_1 = 2080 — higher than Mg. But option (d) makes Z = Cl, which contradicts Z having LOWER IE than Mg.

So only option (c): X = Ar, Y = Cl, Z = Na fits all three conditions.

⚠️ The trap Option (b) places Li with Mg — Li does have a low IEIE but the question says X, Y are HIGHER than Mg, and Z is LOWER. Li has IE1=520<737IE_1 = 520 < 737, so Li belongs in the Z slot, not the X/Y slot. Always check whether each candidate is above or below the reference before assigning.

Answer: (c)\boxed{\text{Answer: (c)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Classification of Elements & Periodicity) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The first ionization energy of magnesium is smaller, as compared to that of elements X and Y, but… (JEE Main 2021) | Canvas Classes