Three elements X, Y and Z are in the 3rd period. The oxides of X, Y and Z, respectively, are basic, amphoteric and…
Classification of Elements & Periodicity · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question
Three elements X, Y and Z are in the 3rd period. The oxides of X, Y and Z, respectively, are basic, amphoteric and acidic. The correct order of the atomic numbers of X, Y and Z is:
- a
Z < Y < X
- b✓
X < Y < Z
- c
X < Z < Y
- d
Y < X < Z
X < Y < Z
🧠 In Period 3, oxide nature shifts left-to-right: basic (metal) → amphoteric (boundary) → acidic (non-metal). So basic = lowest Z, acidic = highest Z Going left to right in Period 3: Na, Mg (basic oxides) → Al (amphoteric oxide) → Si (weakly acidic) → P, S, Cl (acidic oxides). The same direction in which oxide nature changes is the direction in which increases.
🗺️ Place X, Y, Z X has a basic oxide → X is a metal on the left of Period 3 → low (e.g., Na, Mg). Y has an amphoteric oxide → Y is in the middle → intermediate (Al). Z has an acidic oxide → Z is a non-metal on the right → high (Si–Cl range).
So: , i.e., X < Y < Z.
⚠️ The trap Don't mix up the element label Z with the atomic number notation . The question says X, Y, Z are three different elements — so "atomic number of Z" means atomic number of the third element. Read carefully so the symbols don't tangle.
Practice this question with progress tracking
Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Classification of Elements & Periodicity) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.
More JEE Main Classification of Elements & Periodicity PYQs
The nature of oxide (TeO2) and hydride (TeH2) formed by Te, respectively are:
Group-13 elements react with O2 to form oxides of type M2O3. Which among the following is the most basic oxide?
Which pair of oxides is acidic in nature?
The set in which compounds have different nature is:
The acidic, basic and amphoteric oxides, respectively, are: