JEE Main · 2020 · Shift-IIeasyPERI-086

Within each pair of elements F and Cl, S and Se, and Li and Na, respectively, the elements that release more energy…

Classification of Elements & Periodicity · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Within each pair of elements F and Cl, S and Se, and Li and Na, respectively, the elements that release more energy upon an electron gain are:

Options
  1. a

    Cl, Se and Na

  2. b

    Cl, S and Li

  3. c

    F, S and Li

  4. d

    F, Se and Na

Correct Answerb

Cl, S and Li

Detailed Solution

🧠 "Releases more energy on electron gain" = more negative ΔegH\Delta_{eg}H. Pick the more exothermic member of each pair Three independent pair comparisons. Get each right by knowing the small but important anomalies.

🗺️ Pair 1 — F vs Cl \ceF=328\ce{F} = -328, \ceCl=349\ce{Cl} = -349. Cl is more negative. Cl wins. (F's 2p2p shell is too cramped.)

Pair 2 — S vs Se \ceS=200\ce{S} = -200, \ceSe=195\ce{Se} = -195. S is more negative. S wins. (Standard Period 3 > Period 4 trend for Group 16, since Period 2 (O) is the anomaly here, not Period 3.)

Pair 3 — Li vs Na \ceLi=60\ce{Li} = -60, \ceNa=53\ce{Na} = -53. Li is slightly more negative. Li wins. (Despite both being alkali metals with low EGE magnitude, Li edges out Na because the smaller Li atom holds the new 2s22s^2 electron pair more tightly.)

So the answer set is Cl, S, Li.

⚠️ The trap Students often pick (c) F, S, Li — they correctly remember "smaller atom wins for electron gain" and apply it everywhere. The S and Li picks are correct. But for halogens, the rule flips: F is too small, so Cl wins. Memorize: F < Cl in ΔegH|\Delta_{eg}H|, but in Group 16 and Group 1, the smaller-period member usually still wins (S > Se, Li > Na).

Answer: (b)\boxed{\text{Answer: (b)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Classification of Elements & Periodicity) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Within each pair of elements F and Cl, S and Se, and Li and Na, respectively, the elements that… (JEE Main 2020) | Canvas Classes