JEE Main · 2019 · Shift-IImediumHC-062

Which one of the following alkenes when treated with HCl yields majorly an anti-Markovnikov product?

Hydrocarbons · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which one of the following alkenes when treated with HCl yields majorly an anti-Markovnikov product?

Options
  1. a

    \ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}

  2. b

    \ceClCH=CH2\ce{Cl-CH=CH2}

  3. c

    \ceCH3OCH=CH2\ce{CH3O-CH=CH2}

  4. d

    \ceH2NCH=CH2\ce{H2N-CH=CH2}

Correct Answera

\ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Understand when anti-Markovnikov addition occurs

For HCl addition to alkenes:

  • Markovnikov: \ceH+\ce{H^+} adds to the carbon with more H atoms; carbocation forms at the more substituted carbon
  • Anti-Markovnikov: occurs when the more substituted carbon is destabilized (cannot support positive charge)

Step 2: Analyze the effect of substituents

(a) \ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}: The \ceCF3\ce{-CF3} group is strongly electron-withdrawing (by induction and field effect):

  • \ceH+\ce{H^+} adds to C2 (\ce=CH2\ce{=CH2}) would give primary carbocation at C2
  • \ceH+\ce{H^+} adds to C1 (\ce=CHCF3\ce{=CH-CF3}) would give secondary carbocation at C2
  • BUT: \ceCF3\ce{-CF3} destabilizes the adjacent carbocation by its strong I-I effect
  • Therefore, \ceH+\ce{H+} adds to C1 (adjacent to \ceCF3\ce{CF3}) → carbocation at C2 (away from \ceCF3\ce{CF3})
  • Product: \ceCl\ce{Cl} at C1 → anti-Markovnikov

(b)–(d) Substituents like \ceCl\ce{-Cl}, \ceOCH3\ce{-OCH3}, \ceNH2\ce{-NH2} donate electrons via resonance (+M effect), stabilizing adjacent carbocations → favor Markovnikov addition.

Step 3: Conclusion

\ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2} (trifluoropropene) gives anti-Markovnikov addition with HCl due to the powerful electron-withdrawing \ceCF3\ce{-CF3} group destabilizing the adjacent carbocation.

Answer: Option (a) — \ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}

Key Points to Remember:

  • Strong EWG (like \ceCF3\ce{-CF3}, \ceNO2\ce{-NO2}) adjacent to \ceC=C\ce{C=C} reverses Markovnikov selectivity
  • The carbocation forms at the carbon farther from the EWG
  • EDG (\ceOR\ce{-OR}, \ceNR2\ce{-NR2}) = Markovnikov addition; EWG (\ceCF3\ce{-CF3}) = anti-Markovnikov

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Hydrocarbons) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.