JEE Main · 2019 · Shift-IImediumHC-062

Which one of the following alkenes when treated with HCl yields majorly an anti-Markovnikov product?

Hydrocarbons · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which one of the following alkenes when treated with HCl yields majorly an anti-Markovnikov product?

Options
  1. a

    \ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}

  2. b

    \ceClCH=CH2\ce{Cl-CH=CH2}

  3. c

    \ceCH3OCH=CH2\ce{CH3O-CH=CH2}

  4. d

    \ceH2NCH=CH2\ce{H2N-CH=CH2}

Correct Answera

\ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}

Detailed Solution

Step 1: Understand when anti-Markovnikov addition occurs

For HCl addition to alkenes:

  • Markovnikov: \ceH+\ce{H^+} adds to the carbon with more H atoms; carbocation forms at the more substituted carbon
  • Anti-Markovnikov: occurs when the more substituted carbon is destabilized (cannot support positive charge)

Step 2: Analyze the effect of substituents

(a) \ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}: The \ceCF3\ce{-CF3} group is strongly electron-withdrawing (by induction and field effect):

  • \ceH+\ce{H^+} adds to C2 (\ce=CH2\ce{=CH2}) would give primary carbocation at C2
  • \ceH+\ce{H^+} adds to C1 (\ce=CHCF3\ce{=CH-CF3}) would give secondary carbocation at C2
  • BUT: \ceCF3\ce{-CF3} destabilizes the adjacent carbocation by its strong I-I effect
  • Therefore, \ceH+\ce{H+} adds to C1 (adjacent to \ceCF3\ce{CF3}) → carbocation at C2 (away from \ceCF3\ce{CF3})
  • Product: \ceCl\ce{Cl} at C1 → anti-Markovnikov

(b)–(d) Substituents like \ceCl\ce{-Cl}, \ceOCH3\ce{-OCH3}, \ceNH2\ce{-NH2} donate electrons via resonance (+M effect), stabilizing adjacent carbocations → favor Markovnikov addition.

Step 3: Conclusion

\ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2} (trifluoropropene) gives anti-Markovnikov addition with HCl due to the powerful electron-withdrawing \ceCF3\ce{-CF3} group destabilizing the adjacent carbocation.

Answer: Option (a) — \ceF3CCH=CH2\ce{F3C-CH=CH2}

Key Points to Remember:

  • Strong EWG (like \ceCF3\ce{-CF3}, \ceNO2\ce{-NO2}) adjacent to \ceC=C\ce{C=C} reverses Markovnikov selectivity
  • The carbocation forms at the carbon farther from the EWG
  • EDG (\ceOR\ce{-OR}, \ceNR2\ce{-NR2}) = Markovnikov addition; EWG (\ceCF3\ce{-CF3}) = anti-Markovnikov

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Hydrocarbons) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Which one of the following alkenes when treated with HCl yields majorly an anti-Markovnikov product? (JEE Main 2019) | Canvas Classes