JEE Main · 2025 · Shift-IImediumATOM-212

Given below are two statements: Statement (I): It is impossible to specify simultaneously, with arbitrary precision,…

Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Given below are two statements:

Statement (I): It is impossible to specify simultaneously, with arbitrary precision, both the linear momentum and the position of a particle.

Statement (II): If the uncertainty in the measurement of position and uncertainty in measurement of momentum are equal for an electron, then the uncertainty in the measurement of velocity is hπ×12m\geq \sqrt{\dfrac{h}{\pi}} \times \dfrac{1}{2m}.

In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below:

Options
  1. a

    Statement I is true but Statement II is false.

  2. b

    Both Statement I and Statement II are true.

  3. c

    Statement I is false but Statement II is true.

  4. d

    Both Statement I and Statement II are false.

Correct Answerb

Both Statement I and Statement II are true.

Detailed Solution

🧠 The "Aha!" Moment Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle is the "speed limit" of information in the universe. It isn't a failure of our tools, but a fundamental property of nature. Statement I is the direct law. Statement II is a specific mathematical case where we try to balance the scales perfectly between position and momentum.

🗺️ The Proof for Statement II

  1. The Principle: ΔxΔph4π\Delta x \cdot \Delta p \ge \frac{h}{4\pi}
  2. The Condition: If uncertainties in position and momentum are equal (Δx=Δp\Delta x = \Delta p): (Δp)2h4π    Δph4π=12hπ(\Delta p)^2 \ge \frac{h}{4\pi} \implies \Delta p \ge \sqrt{\frac{h}{4\pi}} = \frac{1}{2} \sqrt{\frac{h}{\pi}}
  3. Link to Velocity: Since momentum uncertainty is Δp=mΔv\Delta p = m \Delta v: mΔv12hπ    Δv12mhπm \Delta v \ge \frac{1}{2} \sqrt{\frac{h}{\pi}} \implies \Delta v \ge \frac{1}{2m} \sqrt{\frac{h}{\pi}} Both statements are mathematically and conceptually flawless.

The Equal Uncertainty Trap If you ever see a problem where Δx=Δp\Delta x = \Delta p, remember that the uncertainty in velocity will always involve a square root of Planck's constant (hh). It’s a common "numerical shortcut" in competitive physics.

⚠️ Watch the Pi! h/4π\sqrt{h/4\pi} simplifies to 12h/π\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{h/\pi}. Don't let the placement of the 1/21/2 throw you off; it's simply the square root of the 1/41/4 that sits inside the original principle.

Answer: (b)\boxed{\text{Answer: (b)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Given below are two statements: Statement (I): It is impossible to specify simultaneously, with… (JEE Main 2025) | Canvas Classes