JEE Main · 2022 · Shift-IeasyATOM-051

Identify the incorrect statement from the following:

Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Identify the incorrect statement from the following:

Options
  1. a

    A circular path around the nucleus in which an electron moves is proposed as Bohr's orbit.

  2. b

    An orbital is the one electron wave function.

  3. c

    The existence of Bohr's orbits is supported by hydrogen spectrum.

  4. d

    Atomic orbital is characterised by the quantum numbers nn and ll only.

Correct Answerd

Atomic orbital is characterised by the quantum numbers nn and ll only.

Detailed Solution

🧠 Quantum vs. Classical Audit Bohr's model was a bridge between classical views (circular paths) and quantum mechanics (wave functions). We need to spot the one statement that oversimplifies the modern orbital definition.

🗺️ The Conceptual Filter

  • Statement (1): Bohr did indeed propose the "circular path" planetary model. Correct.
  • Statement (2): Technically, an orbital describes the spatial domain of a single electron's wave function (ψ\psi). Correct.
  • Statement (3): The distinct lines of the H-spectrum were the exact proof Bohr used for quantized orbits. Correct.
  • Statement (4): Says an orbital is characterized by nn and ll only.
    • The Flaw: An atomic orbital requires three quantum numbers to define its shape and orientation: n,l,n, l, and mlm_l. Missing mlm_l makes the description incomplete. Incorrect.

The "Three vs. Two" Rule Remember the hierarchy:

  • Shell     n\implies n (1 quantum number)
  • Subshell     n,l\implies n, l (2 quantum numbers)
  • Orbital     n,l,ml\implies n, l, m_l (3 quantum numbers)
  • Electron     n,l,ml,s\implies n, l, m_l, s (4 quantum numbers) Seeing "orbital" and "only nn and ll" is an immediate conceptual mismatch.

⚠️ Common Traps Don't confuse "orbital" with "subshell." A subshell (like 2p) is indeed defined by nn and ll. But the orbital (like 2pz2p_z) needs mlm_l. Read the subject of the sentence carefully!

Answer: (d)\boxed{\text{Answer: (d)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Identify the incorrect statement from the following: (JEE Main 2022) | Canvas Classes