JEE Main · 2020mediumCORD-088

Among (a)-(d), the complexes that can show geometrical isomerism are: (a) [Pt(NH3)3Cl]+ (b) [Pt(NH3)Cl5]- (c)…

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Among (a)-(d), the complexes that can show geometrical isomerism are: (a) [Pt(NH3)3Cl]+[\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_3Cl}]^+ (b) [Pt(NH3)Cl5][\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)Cl_5}]^- (c) [Pt(NH3)2Cl(NO2)][\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_2Cl(NO_2)}] (d) [Pt(NH3)4ClBr]2+[\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_4ClBr}]^{2+}

Options
  1. a

    b and c

  2. b

    d and a

  3. c

    c and d

  4. d

    a and b

Correct Answerc

c and d

Detailed Solution

🧠 Geometrical Isomerism Needs at Least 2 Distinguishable Positions

For a Pt(IV) octahedral or Pt(II) square-planar complex to show cis/trans (geometrical) isomerism, you need at least two different ligand types arranged in cis vs trans positions.

🗺️ Test Each

| Complex | Layout | Geometrical isomerism? | |---|---|---| | (a) [Pt(NH3)3Cl]+[\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_3Cl}]^+ | [MA3B]\mathrm{[MA_3B]} octahedral — 3 NH₃ + 1 Cl + need 2 more sites! Wait — only 4 ligands listed (CN=4). Square-planar [MA3B]\mathrm{[MA_3B]} → only 1 arrangement | ✗ | | (b) [Pt(NH3)Cl5][\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)Cl_5}]^- | octahedral [MAB5]\mathrm{[MAB_5]} — 1 distinct + 5 identical → only 1 arrangement | ✗ | | (c) [Pt(NH3)2Cl(NO2)][\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_2Cl(NO_2)}] | square-planar [MA2BC]\mathrm{[MA_2BC]} — NH₃ pair can be cis or trans | ✓ | | (d) [Pt(NH3)4ClBr]2+[\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_4ClBr}]^{2+} | octahedral [MA4BC]\mathrm{[MA_4BC]} — Cl/Br can be cis or trans | ✓ |

So (c) and (d) show geometrical isomerism → option (3).

The "Single Identical Ligand" Death Knell

If five (or more) ligands are identical and only one is different ([MAB5]\mathrm{[MAB_5]}), there's only one possible arrangement — no geometrical isomerism. Same for [MA3B]\mathrm{[MA_3B]} in any geometry.

⚠️ Always Identify the Geometry First

Pt(II) (4-coordinate) is square-planar; Pt(IV) (6-coordinate) is octahedral. The isomer count rules are very different. (b) is octahedral, (c) is square-planar — always check geometry before counting.

Answer: (3) c and d\boxed{\text{Answer: (3) c and d}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Among (a)-(d), the complexes that can show geometrical isomerism are: (a) [Pt(NH3)3Cl]+ (b)… (JEE Main 2020) | Canvas Classes