JEE Main · 2020mediumCORD-209

The complex that can show optical activity is:

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The complex that can show optical activity is:

Options
  1. a

    trans-[Cr(Cl2)(ox)2]3[\mathrm{Cr(Cl_2)(ox)_2}]^{3-}

  2. b

    trans-[Fe(NH3)2(CN)4][\mathrm{Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4}]^-

  3. c

    cis-[Fe(NH3)2(CN)4][\mathrm{Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4}]^-

  4. d

    cis-[CrCl2(ox)2]3[\mathrm{CrCl_2(ox)_2}]^{3-} (ox = oxalate)

Correct Answerd

cis-[CrCl2(ox)2]3[\mathrm{CrCl_2(ox)_2}]^{3-} (ox = oxalate)

Detailed Solution

🧠 Look for Lack of Mirror Symmetry

A complex is optically active if it has no mirror plane, no centre of inversion, no improper axis. cis-bisbidentate octahedrals with two extra ligands are the classic chiral motif.

🗺️ Evaluate Each

| Complex | Symmetry | Optical activity | |---|---|---| | trans-[CrCl2(ox)2]3[\mathrm{CrCl_2(ox)_2}]^{3-} | Has σh\sigma_h plane | ✗ achiral | | trans-[Fe(NH3)2(CN)4][\mathrm{Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4}]^- | Has σ\sigma planes (D4hD_{4h}) | ✗ achiral | | cis-[Fe(NH3)2(CN)4][\mathrm{Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4}]^- | Has σ\sigma plane through CN ligands | ✗ achiral | | cis-[CrCl2(ox)2]3[\mathrm{CrCl_2(ox)_2}]^{3-} | C2C_2 only, no mirror plane | ✓ chiral (Δ/Λ) |

🗺️ Why cis-[M(AA)2X2][M(AA)_2 X_2] is Chiral

Two cis Cl⁻ ligands occupy adjacent positions; the two oxalate ligands wrap diagonally around the metal. The resulting structure has only a C2C_2 axis (passing through the midpoints of Cl-Cl and one oxalate). No mirror planes → chiral.

🗺️ Why trans Isomer is Achiral

In trans-[CrCl2(ox)2]3[\mathrm{CrCl_2(ox)_2}]^{3-}, the two Cl⁻ are at axial positions (180° apart). The two oxalates lie in the equatorial plane and are related by a σh\sigma_h mirror plane. → achiral.

Cis-Trans Chirality Quick Test

| Geometry | Chiral? | |---|---| | cis-[M(AA)2X2][M(AA)_2 X_2] | ✓ (Δ/Λ) | | trans-[M(AA)2X2][M(AA)_2 X_2] | ✗ | | cis-[MA2B4][M A_2 B_4] (mono only) | ✗ | | [M(AA)3][M(AA)_3] | ✓ |

⚠️ Identical Mono-Ligands ≠ Chiral

[Fe(NH3)2(CN)4][\mathrm{Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4}]^- has only mono-ligands. Cis or trans, mirror symmetry exists in both — neither is chiral.

Answer: (4) cis-[CrCl2(ox)2]3\boxed{\text{Answer: (4) cis-}[\mathrm{CrCl_2(ox)_2}]^{3-}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The complex that can show optical activity is: (JEE Main 2020) | Canvas Classes