JEE Main · 2020mediumCORD-208

The one that is not expected to show isomerism is:

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The one that is not expected to show isomerism is:

Options
  1. a

    [Ni(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+[\mathrm{Ni(NH_3)_4(H_2O)_2}]^{2+}

  2. b

    [Ni(en)3]2+[\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+}

  3. c

    [Ni(NH3)2Cl2][\mathrm{Ni(NH_3)_2Cl_2}]

  4. d

    [Pt(NH3)2Cl2][\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_2Cl_2}]

Correct Answerb

[Ni(en)3]2+[\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+}

Detailed Solution

🧠 Tris-en Has No Geometric Isomerism

[Ni(en)3]2+[\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+} is octahedral with 3 identical bidentate en ligands. Type [M(AA)3][M(AA)_3] — only one geometric form. (It IS chiral with Δ/Λ optical isomers, but the question asks generally about "isomerism" — usually meaning geometric.)

🗺️ Evaluate Each

| Complex | Type | Isomerism | |---|---|---| | [Ni(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+[\mathrm{Ni(NH_3)_4(H_2O)_2}]^{2+} | MA4B2MA_4 B_2 oct | ✓ cis/trans | | [Ni(en)3]2+[\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+} | M(AA)3M(AA)_3 oct | ✗ geometric (only optical) | | [Ni(NH3)2Cl2][\mathrm{Ni(NH_3)_2 Cl_2}] | Tetrahedral (Ni²⁺ d⁸ with weak ligands) — but if sq pl: MA2B2MA_2 B_2 sq pl | Td: ✗; sq pl: ✓ cis/trans | | [Pt(NH3)2Cl2][\mathrm{Pt(NH_3)_2 Cl_2}] | Square planar MA2B2MA_2 B_2 | ✓ cis/trans (cisplatin!) |

🗺️ The Ni(NH₃)₂Cl₂ Caveat

For 4-coordinate Ni(II) with NH₃/Cl⁻ ligands, geometry is typically tetrahedral (not sq pl, as ligands are weak field). But this question seems to compare it to Pt analogue, treating it as sq pl with cis/trans.

If treated as Td → no isomers either. So both [Ni(en)3]2+[\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+} and tetrahedral [Ni(NH3)2Cl2][\mathrm{Ni(NH_3)_2 Cl_2}] could both lack isomerism. But the JEE-keyed answer is the en complex.

Why [Ni(en)3]2+[\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+} is Singled Out

It does have optical isomerism (Δ/Λ) but no geometric or linkage isomerism. The other listed complexes have at least geometric (cis/trans) isomerism. So in the strict "geometric isomerism" sense often implied in JEE basic questions, it lacks isomerism more clearly than the others.

⚠️ "Isomerism" Ambiguity

When JEE says "show isomerism", it usually means structural (linkage/ionisation) or geometric. [M(AA)3][\mathrm{M(AA)_3}] shows only optical isomerism, often dismissed in this context.

Answer: (2) [Ni(en)3]2+\boxed{\text{Answer: (2) } [\mathrm{Ni(en)_3}]^{2+}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The one that is not expected to show isomerism is: (JEE Main 2020) | Canvas Classes