Choose the incorrect statement about Dalton's Atomic Theory.
Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question
Choose the incorrect statement about Dalton's Atomic Theory.
- a
Chemical reactions involve reorganization of atoms.
- b
Matter consists of indivisible atoms.
- c✓
Compounds are formed when atoms of different elements combine in any ratio.
- d
All the atoms of a given element have identical properties including identical mass.
Compounds are formed when atoms of different elements combine in any ratio.
🧠 Spotting the False Logic Dalton's theory was built on the laws of chemical combination. We are looking for the statement that breaks one of these fundamental laws.
🗺️ Logic Audit Looking at Option (c): "Compounds are formed when atoms of different elements combine in any ratio." Dalton stated the exact opposite in his law of definite proportions: atoms combine in fixed, whole-number ratios. Water is always , not "any ratio" of and .
⚡ The "Ratio" Red Flag Any mention of "any ratio" or "random proportion" in early atomic theory is almost always the false statement. Scientific theories of that era were based on rigorous stoichiometry which demands fixed ratios.
⚠️ Common Traps Be careful with Option (d): "atoms of a given element have identical mass." This statement is true according to Dalton, even though it's false in modern chemistry (due to isotopes). Always strictly follow the historical model the question asks for.
Practice this question with progress tracking
Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.
More JEE Main Structure of Atom PYQs
The incorrect postulates of Dalton's atomic theory are: (A) Atoms of different elements differ in mass. (B) Matter consists of divisible atoms. (C) Compounds form when atoms combine in a fixed ratio.…
Which one of the following sets of ions represents a collection of isoelectronic species? (Atomic numbers: F = 9, Cl = 17, Na = 11, Mg = 12, Al = 13, K = 19, Ca = 20, Sc = 21)
Which of the following pair is not isoelectronic? (Atomic numbers: Sm = 62, Er = 68, Yb = 70, Lu = 71, Eu = 63, Tb = 65, Tm = 69)
The pair in which ions are isoelectronic with Al3+ is:
The isoelectronic set of ions is: