JEE Main · 2023 · Shift-IIeasyATOM-005

Which one of the following sets of ions represents a collection of isoelectronic species? (Atomic numbers: F = 9, Cl =…

Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which one of the following sets of ions represents a collection of isoelectronic species?

(Atomic numbers: F = 9, Cl = 17, Na = 11, Mg = 12, Al = 13, K = 19, Ca = 20, Sc = 21)

Options
  1. a

    Li+,Na+,Mg2+,Ca2+\mathrm{Li^+, Na^+, Mg^{2+}, Ca^{2+}}

  2. b

    Ba2+,Sr2+,K+,Ca2+\mathrm{Ba^{2+}, Sr^{2+}, K^+, Ca^{2+}}

  3. c

    N3,O2,F,S2\mathrm{N^{3-}, O^{2-}, F^-, S^{2-}}

  4. d

    K+,Cl,Ca2+,Sc3+\mathrm{K^+, Cl^-, Ca^{2+}, Sc^{3+}}

Correct Answerd

K+,Cl,Ca2+,Sc3+\mathrm{K^+, Cl^-, Ca^{2+}, Sc^{3+}}

Detailed Solution

🧠 The Periodic Table Scan The question gives you atomic numbers as clues. We are looking for a set of species where the sum of (Atomic Number - Charge) is constant for all.

🗺️ Testing the Suspects Let's check Option (d):

  • \ceK+\ce{K^+}: 191=18 e19 - 1 = 18 \text{ e}^-
  • \ceCl\ce{Cl^-}: 17(1)=18 e17 - (-1) = 18 \text{ e}^-
  • \ceCa2+\ce{Ca^2+}: 202=18 e20 - 2 = 18 \text{ e}^-
  • \ceSc3+\ce{Sc^3+}: 213=18 e21 - 3 = 18 \text{ e}^- Since all possess 18 electrons (making them isoelectronic with Argon), this is our winner.

The Group Mismatch Filter Look at Option (a): \ceLi+,Na+,Mg2+,Ca2+\ce{Li^+, Na^+, Mg^2+, Ca^2+}. These are all cations, but they belong to different shells. \ceLi+\ce{Li^+} has 2 electrons, while \ceNa+\ce{Na^+} has 10. They can't possibly be isoelectronic. You can eliminate options like this in seconds by noticing "shell jumping."

⚠️ Common Traps Watch out for Option (c): \ceN3,O2,F\ce{N^3-, O^2-, F^-} (10 e10 \text{ e}^-) and \ceS2\ce{S^2-} (18 e18 \text{ e}^-). One heavy ion like \ceS2\ce{S^2-} ruins the entire set. Always check every member, not just the first three!

Answer: (d)\boxed{\text{Answer: (d)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Which one of the following sets of ions represents a collection of isoelectronic species? (Atomic… (JEE Main 2023) | Canvas Classes