JEE Main · 2022 · Shift-IImediumATOM-007

Which of the following pair is not isoelectronic? (Atomic numbers: Sm = 62, Er = 68, Yb = 70, Lu = 71, Eu = 63, Tb =…

Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which of the following pair is not isoelectronic?

(Atomic numbers: Sm = 62, Er = 68, Yb = 70, Lu = 71, Eu = 63, Tb = 65, Tm = 69)

Options
  1. a

    Sm2+\mathrm{Sm^{2+}} and Er3+\mathrm{Er^{3+}}

  2. b

    Yb2+\mathrm{Yb^{2+}} and Lu3+\mathrm{Lu^{3+}}

  3. c

    Eu2+\mathrm{Eu^{2+}} and Tb4+\mathrm{Tb^{4+}}

  4. d

    Tb2+\mathrm{Tb^{2+}} and Tm4+\mathrm{Tm^{4+}}

Correct Answerd

Tb2+\mathrm{Tb^{2+}} and Tm4+\mathrm{Tm^{4+}}

Detailed Solution

🧠 The Lanthanoid Challenge This question tests your knowledge of f-block elements and their typical 2+,3+,4+2+, 3+, 4+ states. We need to find the pair where the (Atomic Number - Charge) mismatch identifies them as NOT isoelectronic.

🗺️ The Electronic Audit Let's check the options one by one:

  • Option (b): YbX2+(702=68)\ce{Yb^2+} (70 - 2 = 68) and LuX3+(713=68)\ce{Lu^3+} (71 - 3 = 68). These match!
  • Option (c): EuX2+(632=61)\ce{Eu^2+} (63 - 2 = 61) and TbX4+(654=61)\ce{Tb^4+} (65 - 4 = 61). These match too!
  • Option (d): TbX2+(652=63)\ce{Tb^2+} (65 - 2 = 63) and TmX4+(694=65)\ce{Tm^4+} (69 - 4 = 65). Here, 636563 \neq 65. They are NOT isoelectronic.

The Quick Delta Check Instead of counting electrons, look at the difference in atomic numbers vs. the difference in charges. For Option (b): ΔZ=1\Delta Z = 1, ΔCharge=1\Delta \text{Charge} = 1. Mismatch in ZZ is compensated by mismatch in charge. Isoelectronic! For Option (d): ΔZ=6965=4\Delta Z = 69 - 65 = 4. ΔCharge=42=2\Delta \text{Charge} = 4 - 2 = 2. The charge shift (22) doesn't cover the ZZ gap (44). Instant rejection!

⚠️ Common Traps Rare earth elements (Lanthanoids) can be scary because of high atomic numbers. Don't panic. The logic is identical to simple ions: Proton count minus charge. You don't need to write the full 4f4f configuration to find the electron count.

Answer: (d)\boxed{\text{Answer: (d)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

Which of the following pair is not isoelectronic? (Atomic numbers: Sm = 62, Er = 68, Yb = 70, Lu =… (JEE Main 2022) | Canvas Classes