JEE Main · 2022 · Shift-IImediumATOM-007

Which of the following pair is not isoelectronic? (Atomic numbers: Sm = 62, Er = 68, Yb = 70, Lu = 71, Eu = 63, Tb =…

Structure of Atom · Class 11 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

Which of the following pair is not isoelectronic?

(Atomic numbers: Sm = 62, Er = 68, Yb = 70, Lu = 71, Eu = 63, Tb = 65, Tm = 69)

Options
  1. a

    Sm2+\mathrm{Sm^{2+}} and Er3+\mathrm{Er^{3+}}

  2. b

    Yb2+\mathrm{Yb^{2+}} and Lu3+\mathrm{Lu^{3+}}

  3. c

    Eu2+\mathrm{Eu^{2+}} and Tb4+\mathrm{Tb^{4+}}

  4. d

    Tb2+\mathrm{Tb^{2+}} and Tm4+\mathrm{Tm^{4+}}

Correct Answerd

Tb2+\mathrm{Tb^{2+}} and Tm4+\mathrm{Tm^{4+}}

Detailed Solution

🧠 The Lanthanoid Challenge This question tests your knowledge of f-block elements and their typical 2+,3+,4+2+, 3+, 4+ states. We need to find the pair where the (Atomic Number - Charge) mismatch identifies them as NOT isoelectronic.

🗺️ The Electronic Audit Let's check the options one by one:

  • Option (b): \ceYb2+(702=68)\ce{Yb^2+} (70 - 2 = 68) and \ceLu3+(713=68)\ce{Lu^3+} (71 - 3 = 68). These match!
  • Option (c): \ceEu2+(632=61)\ce{Eu^2+} (63 - 2 = 61) and \ceTb4+(654=61)\ce{Tb^4+} (65 - 4 = 61). These match too!
  • Option (d): \ceTb2+(652=63)\ce{Tb^2+} (65 - 2 = 63) and \ceTm4+(694=65)\ce{Tm^4+} (69 - 4 = 65). Here, 636563 \neq 65. They are NOT isoelectronic.

The Quick Delta Check Instead of counting electrons, look at the difference in atomic numbers vs. the difference in charges. For Option (b): ΔZ=1\Delta Z = 1, ΔCharge=1\Delta \text{Charge} = 1. Mismatch in ZZ is compensated by mismatch in charge. Isoelectronic! For Option (d): ΔZ=6965=4\Delta Z = 69 - 65 = 4. ΔCharge=42=2\Delta \text{Charge} = 4 - 2 = 2. The charge shift (22) doesn't cover the ZZ gap (44). Instant rejection!

⚠️ Common Traps Rare earth elements (Lanthanoids) can be scary because of high atomic numbers. Don't panic. The logic is identical to simple ions: Proton count minus charge. You don't need to write the full 4f4f configuration to find the electron count.

Answer: (d)\boxed{\text{Answer: (d)}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Structure of Atom) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.