JEE Main · 2023hardCORD-009

The mismatched combinations are: A. Chlorophyll – Co B. Water hardness – EDTA C. Photography – [Ag(CN)2]- D. Wilkinson…

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The mismatched combinations are: A. Chlorophyll – Co B. Water hardness – EDTA C. Photography – [Ag(CN)2][\mathrm{Ag(CN)_2}]^- D. Wilkinson catalyst – [(Ph3P)3RhCl][(\mathrm{Ph_3P})_3\mathrm{RhCl}] E. Chelating ligand – D-Penicillamine

Options
  1. a

    A, C and E only

  2. b

    A and C only

  3. c

    A and E only

  4. d

    D and E only

Correct Answerb

A and C only

Detailed Solution

🧠 Two Pillars of Bio/Industrial Chemistry

This question tests two facts that JEE recycles every year:

  1. Chlorophyll — central metal is Mg\mathrm{Mg}, not Co\mathrm{Co}. Cobalt belongs to vitamin B₁₂. The Mg/Co swap is the textbook distractor.
  2. Photographic fixing — uses sodium thiosulfate (Na2S2O3\mathrm{Na_2S_2O_3}, "hypo"), forming [Ag(S2O3)2]3[\mathrm{Ag(S_2O_3)_2}]^{3-}. Not a cyanide complex.

So statements A and C are wrong. Statements B, D, E are textbook-correct.

🗺️ Verify Each Pair

  • A. Chlorophyll – Co. Wrong metal. Should be Mg. ✗
  • B. Water hardness – EDTA. EDTA titration is the standard method. ✓
  • C. Photography – [Ag(CN)2][\mathrm{Ag(CN)_2}]^-. Cyanide is used in silver extraction (MacArthur–Forrest), not photo-fixing. ✗
  • D. Wilkinson catalyst – [(Ph3P)3RhCl][(\mathrm{Ph_3P})_3\mathrm{RhCl}]. Definition. ✓
  • E. Chelating ligand – D-Penicillamine. Penicillamine chelates copper in Wilson's disease. ✓

Mismatches: A and C only.

The "Magnesium Heart" Mnemonic

Anchor the bio-metal centres once and never miss them again:

  • Chlorophyll → Mg (green plant pigment)
  • Haemoglobin → Fe
  • Vitamin B₁₂ → Co
  • Carbonic anhydrase → Zn

If a question pairs chlorophyll with anything other than Mg, kill the option.

⚠️ The Cyanide-Photography Bait

[Ag(CN)2][\mathrm{Ag(CN)_2}]^- is a real complex — it's used for electroplating silver and to extract silver from ores. Photography uses thiosulfate. The two are easy to mix up because both involve dissolving Ag.

Answer: (2) A and C only\boxed{\text{Answer: (2) A and C only}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.

The mismatched combinations are: A. Chlorophyll – Co B. Water hardness – EDTA C. Photography –… (JEE Main 2023) | Canvas Classes