JEE Main · 2023hardCORD-009

The mismatched combinations are: A. Chlorophyll – Co B. Water hardness – EDTA C. Photography – [Ag(CN)2]- D. Wilkinson…

Coordination Compounds · Class 12 · JEE Main Previous Year Question

Question

The mismatched combinations are: A. Chlorophyll – Co B. Water hardness – EDTA C. Photography – [Ag(CN)2][\mathrm{Ag(CN)_2}]^- D. Wilkinson catalyst – [(Ph3P)3RhCl][(\mathrm{Ph_3P})_3\mathrm{RhCl}] E. Chelating ligand – D-Penicillamine

Options
  1. a

    A, C and E only

  2. b

    A and C only

  3. c

    A and E only

  4. d

    D and E only

Correct Answerb

A and C only

Detailed Solution

🧠 Two Pillars of Bio/Industrial Chemistry

This question tests two facts that JEE recycles every year:

  1. Chlorophyll — central metal is Mg\mathrm{Mg}, not Co\mathrm{Co}. Cobalt belongs to vitamin B₁₂. The Mg/Co swap is the textbook distractor.
  2. Photographic fixing — uses sodium thiosulfate (Na2S2O3\mathrm{Na_2S_2O_3}, "hypo"), forming [Ag(S2O3)2]3[\mathrm{Ag(S_2O_3)_2}]^{3-}. Not a cyanide complex.

So statements A and C are wrong. Statements B, D, E are textbook-correct.

🗺️ Verify Each Pair

  • A. Chlorophyll – Co. Wrong metal. Should be Mg. ✗
  • B. Water hardness – EDTA. EDTA titration is the standard method. ✓
  • C. Photography – [Ag(CN)2][\mathrm{Ag(CN)_2}]^-. Cyanide is used in silver extraction (MacArthur–Forrest), not photo-fixing. ✗
  • D. Wilkinson catalyst – [(Ph3P)3RhCl][(\mathrm{Ph_3P})_3\mathrm{RhCl}]. Definition. ✓
  • E. Chelating ligand – D-Penicillamine. Penicillamine chelates copper in Wilson's disease. ✓

Mismatches: A and C only.

The "Magnesium Heart" Mnemonic

Anchor the bio-metal centres once and never miss them again:

  • Chlorophyll → Mg (green plant pigment)
  • Haemoglobin → Fe
  • Vitamin B₁₂ → Co
  • Carbonic anhydrase → Zn

If a question pairs chlorophyll with anything other than Mg, kill the option.

⚠️ The Cyanide-Photography Bait

[Ag(CN)2][\mathrm{Ag(CN)_2}]^- is a real complex — it's used for electroplating silver and to extract silver from ores. Photography uses thiosulfate. The two are easy to mix up because both involve dissolving Ag.

Answer: (2) A and C only\boxed{\text{Answer: (2) A and C only}}

Practice this question with progress tracking

Want timed practice with adaptive difficulty? Solve this question (and hundreds more from Coordination Compounds) inside The Crucible, our adaptive practice platform.